MENU

When a federal jury convicts on some charges and acquits on others, do not cheer before sentencing

Jun 29, 2010 When a federal jury convicts on some charges and acquits on others, do not cheer before sentencing

In federal court, when a jury convicts on some charges and acquits on others, at sentencing the judge still must determine whether the acquitted conduct was proven by a preponderance of the evidence.

This point was driven home yesterday, when the Fourth Circuit remanded a drug sentencing, saying the trial judge “erred by viewing the jury’s drug-quantity determination as precluding the court from finding a higher quantity for sentencing purposes,” so long as the sentence was within the forty-year maximum permitted by the jury’s quantity determination. U.S. v. Young, ___ F.3d ___    (4th Cir., June 28, 2010).

This Young case and the separate sovereigns doctrine are examples of why federal court often is no picnic for criminal defense.

PREVIOUS
NEXT
No Comments

Post A Comment