Evasiveness is not your friend says Fairfax criminal lawyer
Evasiveness is not your friend says Fairfax criminal lawyer
Evasiveness is not your friend with police nor otherwise, says Fairfax criminal lawyer
Evasiveness is not your friend when that activity will become the focus of a police investigation and any prosecution against you. As a Fairfax criminal lawyer, I know the counterproductivity, for instance, in a Virginia DUI prosecution under Virginia Code § 18.2-266 https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title18.2/chapter7/section18.2-266 for the defendant to deny any alcohol consumption when odor and/or behavior show otherwise. Then, sometimes a DWI suspect will later in the police encounter expand the number of drinks they consumed from their initial denial or minimization. What is the solution to this state of affairs? To exercise in the first place one’s Fifth and Sixth Amendment Constitutional rights to remain silent.
Police probably have your cellphone number. Asserting your right to remain silent and terminating the phone call.
Law enforcement officers / LEO have a variety of sources for learning your cellnumber, whether from the motor vehicles department, from a person complaining about you, or otherwise. The cousin of your Constitutional right to remain silent with police is your right to terminate such an incoming call. whether by saying “I gotta go” or otherwis. Beware the evasiveness of saying “I will get back to you” when not meaning that, both because you do not want to provide proof of lying to the police, and should not bind yourself to contact the police when you have no obligation to do so.
What happens if I hide from the police?
Physical evasiveness plays into the hands of the prosecutor’s asking your trial judge to instruct your jury that escape or hiding from arrest may be interpreted as consciousness of guilt. If you believe or know you are a police suspect or that you have an arrest warrant against you, ideally you will timely speak with a qualified criminal defense lawyer, ideally without your hindering taking the right steps in response to that situation.
Here is what happened to a Virginia criminal defendant who with evasiveness drove and spoke with police
Marquie Little is a recent example of a person who exhibited evasiveness to his disadvantage. Little v. Commonwealth of Virginia, Record No. 0420-25-1 (Va. App. 2026) (unpublished). In affirming Little’s conviction for stalking and preliminary protective order violation, the Virginia Supreme Court pointed out that upon being discovered where the protective order barred him, Little drove away. When police called Little on his cellphone and asked if he had been driving his described vehicle, Little responded with an unhelpful statement that he “might have been” driving it, when it is risky for a suspect or potential criminal suspect to waive their Constitutional right to remain silent with police (where that right is not triggered only by police telling you of that right to remain silent, whether pursuant to Miranda v. Arizona or otherwise).
Fairfax criminal lawyer Jonathan Katz knows that plenty of criminal defendants say and do things with police and otherwise that make their defenses all the more a challenge. Jon Katz takes the reality of your case and works to turn matters to your best advantage in pursuing your best defense against Virginia DUI, felony and misdemeanor prosecutions. Secure your free initial in person strictly confidential consultation with Jon about your court-pending prosecution by scheduling with us at 703-383-1100, Info@KatzJustice.com and (text) 571-406-7268.
