Home » Blog » Criminal Defense » Believable testimony must be honest says Fairfax criminal lawyer

Believable testimony must be honest says Fairfax criminal lawyer

Call Us: 703-383-1100

Believable testimony must be honest says Fairfax criminal lawyer- Microphone image

Believable testimony must be honest, says Fairfax criminal lawyer

Believable testimony must be honest. As a Fairfax criminal lawyer, I know that even honest testimony is not always believed, but dishonest testimony is more often disbelieved. When a judge or juror has trouble seeing a story line as within the realm of the possible or reasonable, they will need more convincing. That reminds me of the judge who, when acquitting my client of assault, remarked that until hearing my client’s audiotape of the event, he was skeptical of my assertion at opening statement that the complainant had manufactured an assault claim out of upset from my client’s breaking up with her, where she claimed she had broken up with him. A factfinder (whether a judge or juror) can have more difficulty accepting testimony as true the more that the testimony is hard for the factfinder to fit into their world view and morals and the more serious is the alleged charge.

A criminal defendant’s claim of duress will not always be believed by your judge or jury

Adrian Scales got convicted for violating Virginia’s DUI and felony child endangerment statutes, where he struck another car at high speed while his headlights were off at night, when trying to pass that car when turning left, causing a vertebrae fracture to the other driver. Scales v. Virginia, Record No. 1967-25-3 (Va. App. 2026) (unpublished). Scales’s child in the car remained unharmed, but the Virginia Court of Appeals nonetheless affirmed the latter conviction based on the harm to which Scales exposed the child while driving with a blood alcohol concentration test that resulted in 0.17 (over twice the legal limit). Scales took the witness stand, waived his Fifth Amendment Constitutional right to remain silent, admitted to his drinking and then driving, and claimed duress of his brother’s assaulting him to give him a ride: “Scales testified that his brother had been in the car with him at the time of the incident. He stated that his brother asked him to drive him to Bassett. Scales says that he initially refused because he had been drinking and had his young child with him. He then claims that his brother hit him. Scales felt afraid and felt that he had to comply with his brother’s demand. During the drive, Scales’s brother started punching him repeatedly. Scales asserted that he had lost consciousness while driving and his brother woke him up immediately before the collision. Scales claimed that his brother fled the scene on foot after the crash.” Scales. Scales’s testimony was not believable at all to his bench trial judge.

Scales’s judge found his testimony no believable

Scales’s bench trial judge convicted him, remarking that he “did not ‘believe a single word of’ Scales’s version of the events.” Scales.  Scales’s story was challenging enough to be believable by claiming the duress of his brother hitting him not only to get a ride but even hitting Scales after Scales complied to provide him a ride. Compounding that was that even if Scales was under duress to drive, how does that explain his excessive speed and not having his headlights on? Further challenging the judge’s ability to accept Scales’s testimony was probably the absence of any evidence that his brother was ever a car passenger absent Scales’s own claim.

Even truthful testimony can be discounted. Prepare your testimony with your criminal defense lawyer.

As a Fairfax criminal lawyer, I know that even truthful testimony can be found not to be believable by the fact finder. Make sure that you thoroughly discuss and prepare your testimony (if you are going to waive your right to remain silent and testify as a criminal defendant) with your Virginia criminal defense lawyer well in advance of your trial date, and possibly needing multiple preparation sessions. These discussions must be about presenting your testimony only truthfully. Why, you may ask, must truthful testimony be prepared? If for no other reason, to make sure your lawyer has your full essential story, to assure you are recalling essential details, to be ready for the pressure and stress of being cross examined by the prosecutor and maybe even questioned by your trial judge, and to be ready to explain — in response to your lawyer’s answers — any nervousness you display on the witness stand.

Top-rated Fairfax criminal lawyer Jonathan Katz leaves nothing to chance in relentlessly pursuing your best defense against Virginia DUI, felony and misdemeanor prosecutions. Secure your free in-person initial confidential consultation with Jon about your court-pending Virginia prosecution, by contacting us at 703-383-1100, Info@KatzJustice.com or (text) 571-406-7268. 

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.